Moms of Tweens and Teens

Why Being the “Good Kid” Isn’t All It’s Cracked Up to Be, with Maggie Nick

• Episode 135

Use Left/Right to seek, Home/End to jump to start or end. Hold shift to jump forward or backward.

0:00 | 54:02

Send us Fan Mail

Were you the easy one growing up? The “delight to have in class,” the “old soul,” the one nobody ever had to worry about? Maybe you still ask the people you love, “Are you mad at me?” and walk into a room already reading everyone’s mood. If that’s you, you are so not alone, and this conversation is for you.

This week I sit down with trauma therapist Maggie Nick, LCSW, author of Good Kids: Why You Suffered in Silence and How to Break the Cycle. Maggie shares her own story as a “raging good kid,” what relational shame trauma is, and why so many of us grew up believing something was wrong with us. Then we talk about how to give our tweens and teens something different, whether they’re 11 or 17: holding our boundaries without making them feel unlovable.

In this episode you’ll learn:

  • Why “I’m not mad, I’m just disappointed” hurts so much, and what to say instead
  • How to “stand by” your kid without standing by what they did
  • The one question to ask yourself in the middle of a meltdown: “Can you love me even like this?”
  • Circle backs: how to repair after a hard moment
  • What really leads to mom rage, and why shame only makes it worse
  • How to hold a boundary when your kid is disappointed, without punishing their feelings

Content note: Maggie talks openly about her childhood, including abuse and an eating disorder, and uses some strong language. If little ears are nearby, pop in your earbuds.

Find Maggie and the book: maggienick.com

Follow Maggie on Instagram and TikTok: @maggiewithperspectacles

More support for moms of tweens and teens: momsoftweensandteens.com

Want help with your next step? Email me at sheryl@momsoftweensandteens.com for a free 30-minute call.

If this episode spoke to you, please share it with a friend who was a good kid too. And if no one has told you today, you are loved.

Chapter markers (in Buzzsprout, open the episode → Chapter Markers and add each one)


0:00 Welcome
4:04 Welcome, Maggie Nick
5:16 Maggie's story: "a raging good kid"
8:53 Becoming an accidental expert on shame
9:37 The video that went viral
10:38 The hidden cost of being the easy one
12:07 "Are you mad at me?"
13:43 How anger led me to start Moms of Tweens and Teens
15:48 What is relational shame trauma?
18:36 "I'm not mad, I'm just disappointed"
20:34 Stand by them, not what they did
22:09 The misguided expectations we grew up with
25:07 We all need to be seen as good inside
27:08 "What else do you believe I won't love you through?"
29:48 "Can you love me even like this?"
32:31 Circle backs and "relational colostrum"
34:16 Own your impact: why apologizing makes you a better parent
37:59 What really leads to mom rage
41:47 The stuffy story
43:50 My grandson and the cookie
45:07 Impulse control and checking our expectations
47:03 The 0 to 10 stress scale
48:57 Holding a boundary when they're disappointed
49:58 Where to find Maggie
51:11 Closing thoughts and how to get support

Support the show

Check out What's Waiting For You At Moms of Tweens and Teens 

Find more encouragement, wisdom, and resources:

 Website: https://momsoftweensandteens.com/

Facebook: https://www.facebook.com/momsoftweensandteens/

 Join our Community HERE.

 Find awesome resources HERE.

 Instagram: https://www.instagram.com/momsoftweensandteens/

 Sheryl also has an Inner Circle weekly Parenting Program with a community of like-minded moms, personal coaching, and tons of resources to equip and support you to love well, navigate the challenges and meet your tween and teen’s unique needs during these pivotal years.